Honest Review: Can You Actually Live in This 800 Sq Ft Garage Apartment?

Keep Your Daydream tours an 800 sq ft garage apartment, showcasing its design and functionality. But can you really live in a small space like this? We're diving deep to assess the livability, not just the looks, and offering a no-nonsense perspective on whether this ADU is a practical long-term solution or just a pretty vacation rental. Let's get real about the pros, the cons, and the compromises required to make this tiny home a true home.

Kitchen Realities

The kitchen is undeniably cute, but let's talk practicality. A 27-inch sink and an 18-inch dishwasher? Sure, it's fine for a weekend getaway, but for full-time living, that's going to get old fast. As the hosts admit, it's designed for short stays where guests are "just visiting for a short time." Cooking elaborate meals will be a challenge, and forget about stocking up on groceries. This setup screams "takeout and leftovers," not "home-cooked feasts."

They opted for a cooktop instead of a full oven, a decision that highlights the limited cooking capacity. While convenient for tea or heating up pre-made food, it restricts baking and larger meal preparations. For those who enjoy cooking, this could be a significant drawback. Remember, convenience is traded for functionality in this compact design.

I do appreciate the hidden range hood idea. Hiding it above to create a seamless look adds a lot to the design of the kitchen that doesn't make you feel as though you're in a kitchen. This is a clever way to maximize space and maintain a clean aesthetic, especially in a small area where every inch counts.

Space and Storage Showdown

800 sq ft is not a lot of space to begin with, especially when dividing it into two bedrooms and two bathrooms. While the hosts have done a commendable job maximizing the available area, it's essential to consider the long-term implications of living in such close quarters. Clutter will quickly become your enemy, and organization will be paramount. Every item must have a designated place, and minimalism will be your new mantra.

Storage solutions are key in any small living space. The corner cabinet with the "Productive Susan" is a clever way to utilize dead space. Built-in shelves, custom-made by their carpenter Raphael (found on Thumbtack!), also provide valuable storage without taking up additional floor space. However, it's crucial to realistically assess your storage needs before committing to this lifestyle. Can you downsize your belongings enough to comfortably fit everything in the available space?

The placement of the Amazon counter stools and the countertop overhang is a good illustration of maximizing space without sacrificing comfort. They wanted to ensure there was plenty of room for seating beneath the counter. Every inch needs to be considered in small spaces, and it shows that the designer thought about even the smallest details.

Bathroom Battles

The bathrooms, while aesthetically pleasing, also present some practical considerations. The lack of a bathtub in the blue bathroom might be a deal-breaker for some, especially families with young children. While the wand attachment offers a workaround for rinsing, it's not a substitute for a proper bath. Ask yourself, "How important is a bathtub to my daily routine?"

The darker tile with coordinating grout is a trendy design choice, but it's essential to consider the maintenance implications. Dark grout can be more prone to staining and may require more frequent cleaning to maintain its appearance. While the lighted and defogging mirror is a nice touch, it's a luxury, not a necessity. Be honest with yourself about what features you truly need versus those that are merely desirable.

I appreciated the fact that they repurposed the tile for the floor and along the walls of the pink bathroom. They found a clearance deal and made the most of the materials to cut down on costs and wasted materials. This kind of thinking is essential for DIYers and full-timers alike.

Design Decisions: Form vs. Function

The design choices in this ADU lean heavily towards aesthetics, which is fine for a vacation rental, but not necessarily ideal for full-time living. The "Borrowed Light" blue doors and trim are undeniably charming, but are they worth the potential hassle of repainting if you tire of the color? The antique store finds add character, but do they provide practical storage solutions? As the hosts themselves admit, the design process was a "playground" for them, but it's crucial to remember that a home is more than just a pretty space; it's a functional environment that supports your daily life.

The stackable washer and dryer are a space-saving necessity, but the need for "makeup air" highlights the importance of considering building codes and ventilation requirements. Before embarking on a similar project, consult with professionals to ensure compliance and avoid potential safety hazards. Remember, safety and functionality should always take precedence over aesthetics.

The bedroom size at 12x12 is a really nice size, especially with a king bed. However, the small bedroom doesn't have space for dressers or a larger wardrobe. Storage will need to be considered when deciding what's important in this area. Maybe there is a creative built-in option to explore, or perhaps some hidden storage under the bed.

Key Takeaways

Small spaces require ruthless decluttering: Be prepared to downsize your belongings significantly. If you don't use it regularly, get rid of it.
Multifunctional furniture is a must: Opt for furniture that serves multiple purposes, such as a sofa bed or a coffee table with built-in storage.
Vertical space is your friend: Utilize shelves, wall-mounted organizers, and hanging storage to maximize vertical space and keep surfaces clear.
Prioritize practicality over aesthetics: While a beautiful space is desirable, functionality should always be the primary consideration.
Consult with professionals: Before undertaking any renovation or construction project, consult with qualified contractors and designers to ensure compliance with building codes and safety regulations.
Living small is a lifestyle choice: Be prepared to embrace a minimalist lifestyle and make compromises to live comfortably in a smaller space.